Complaint
Class AL2 Task 10: Decision regarding 424 triangle
Submitted
11 Aug 2010 09:34 BST by
Antonio Marchesi ESP
The 424 has got scoring for a triangle not completed. No considerations about the circunstances of the flight and what happened around turn points, timing gates can be taked in account, as there is a no objetive system to evaluate.
If this decision remains, I can talk about heavy rain at the turn point, other pilots waking "wave flights" close to timing gates and avoiding other´s straight navigation, and even goose crowd crossing a turning point.
Is as simple as if you have passed or not.
In this particular case, reviewing the track not give evidence enough to consider if he has avoided a traffic or he has doubted between the bridge that was 1.5 km south and when I saw the right one didn´t have enough fuel to came back and reached the airlfield.
To get more evidences, may be as the traffic he avoided was a general aviation he can report its registration (it seems that they were very close) and we can check the flight plan to know if this GA aircraft was there.
So we ask to revert this decision and no score the triangle to the 424 aircraft.